Sunday, 4 December 2011

Questioning the Qur'anic human creation story


The sequence of events in Surah Al-A'raaf (has) had me puzzled for quite a while:
  • God creates Adam and Hawwa (Verse 11);
  • they are to reside in Paradise (as we are to find out in Verse 19);
  • the angels and Iblees are commanded by God to prostrate to Adam (Verse 11);
  • Iblees refuses (Verse 11);
  • Iblees is told by God to get down from Paradise (Verse 13);
  • Iblees asks for respite until the day that they (Adam, Hawwa and their offspring) are raised up (from death, for judgement; Verse 14);
  • God grants Iblees this respite (Verse 15).

My first question was: given that Adam and Hawwa were residing in Paradise and Iblees asks for respite until the day that they are raised, does this imply that there would have been death and accountability despite them being in Paradise? But I guess this is answered in that God had earlier said to the angels that He would place successive generations on earth (Surah al-Baqarah, Verse 30), and Iblees was the most learned of the angels (though himself of Jinn-kind).

My second question then is: has Iblees been granted respite and leave to roam in and out of Paradise until the Day of Judgement, given that He must have entered Paradise to have misled Adam and Hawwa as he did (Verses 20-22)? And how do we consolidate this with God's saying to Iblees in Verse 18 to get out from Paradise disgraced and expelled (this after Iblees was granted respite in Verse 15) ?

Another point that sticks out is Iblees' remarkable acknowledgement in Verse 16 that God has sent him astray, but going to leave that for another day...

1 comment:

adil said...

Should clarify: when I say 'questioning' I mean the desire to fill the gaps in my understanding and not that the story is contradictory!